"A PARENT BY ANY OTHER NAME"
"It is a terrible thing to win a battle and lose the war."
by Mikal Frazier, LMFT, LPC
Years ago when I was training as a marriage and family therapist, I had the opportunity to observe a most unfortunate interaction between a mother and her 12-year-old son. As I watched this mom relish her "wins" with this broken child, she was losing the war. Instead of being her child's advocate, she was his adversary and in each of their interactions there was a winner and a loser. When this mother had the child in a position where he had to face a consequence for his behavior, she gloated. Literally, a smile of one-up-man-ship would come over her face as she watched him wilt before her eyes. Sometimes she actually uttered a chuckle. Where this child is now, I shudder to think. It would be highly
unlikely that this mom won the war.
This mom's core problem was her own inner emptiness. Because she was so empty, it was crucial for her to be seen as the parent, for her to be recognized and acknowledged as the one wielding the power. Dr. David Lewis, et al., in their book Dying to Tell describes this kind of parent and likens him/her to the Pharisees. Just as the Pharisees had to declare themselves as the righteous ones in authority, the authoritarian parent
must declare himself/herself as the right one in authority. In each parental interaction, the authoritarian parent must define the status of the relationship. That is, the authoritarian parent is the ruler and the child is subject to this ruler. It is because of the authoritarian parent's emptiness that this validating status of the relationship must be declared. Obedience is sought, not to benevolently train the child, but to validate the parent.
Lewis, et al., compare the Pharisees and their wielding of power to the authority exercised by Jesus. The authoritativeness of Jesus was "expressed in loving compassionate ways," whereas the "authority-loving scribes and Pharisees used their power to intimidate others." The difference is the fullness and confidence of the authoritative parent versus the emptiness and fear of the authoritarian parent. This same emptiness drove the scribes and Pharisees. Lewis, et al., state, "Ironically, the scribes' very exercise of power indicated to the people that their teachers lacked real authority," - EMPTY.
When a parent is truly aware of his/her worth in Jesus and the awesome responsibility of training this child in the nurture and admonition of the Lord, an overt defining of the terms of the relationship is unnecessary and diametrically opposed to the desired goal. Yes, I believe whole-heartedly that parents are to be in charge. Parents are to set firm limits and have definite consequences in place when those limits are violated. The only effective manner in which this training can be done is through authoritative parenting.
The authoritative parent requires obedience, but it is for the benefit of the child. The message of discipline is always given with compassion, not with gloating and one-up-man-ship. Foster Cline and Jim Fay have a series of books on parenting and grand parenting with the theme of Parenting with Love and Logic. This theme is the title of one of their books and is included in the titles of their other books. This idea of parenting with love and logic is a wonderful example of authoritative parenting with
compassion.
One of the core points of parenting with love and logic is giving
consequences with sorrow. This is one of the main things I work on with parents. Have the consequence in place. Give the consequence, but administer it with compassion and sorrow. This way you become your child's advocate and not his adversary. Advocates are authoritative.
As Jim and I parented our three children, we failed at this many times. But there is one situation where we obtained a solid level of authoritative parenthood expressed with compassion. Our son was just a few months from being able to take his driving test here in Louisiana. At that time he could get his license when he turned 15 years of age. Well, Jamey was also bringing home some atrocious grades. Jim and I were in turmoil with each other and with him over this issue. Finally we came to our senses and decided to act like authoritative parents instead of helpless, out-of-control, confused parents. We attached his privilege of
getting his driver's license to his making acceptable grades. Anything below a "C" on his report card would result in delaying his driver's license for six weeks. Well, he was delayed several months, but the most important change we made as parents is that we were able to become his advocate and administer the consequence with sorrow. When that report card came in, we very calmly said, "Well, Jamey, we're sorry Babe, but you know what that means." He knew. There was no quarreling. We did not
need any validation as to our position as parent. We were now acting like parents.
Oh, yeah. And how did our story turn out? It was summertime before he received his driver's license and a form of the same rule stayed in effect for the next year. A grade below a "C" would put the driver's license up for six weeks. That year he stayed on the "B" Honor Roll.
We were the parents. We did not need that to be acknowledged or
validated. Our only purpose was to train our son for his benefit. A parent by any other name:
* * * * *
PERCEPTIONS
"When Brethren Disagree"
by Reuel Lemmons
Editorial in the Firm Foundation
May 8, 1962
We often think of conflict in negative terms. Conflict often implies confusion, instability, poor attitudes, lack of love, divisiveness, rancor and bitterness. Indeed all those things can take place when we disagree, but disagreement can become a catalyst for spiritual growth. The late Reuel Lemmons left behind some important thoughts on the way we handle disagreements. You can read them
at
http://www.allaboutfamilies.org/sh/percep200039.html
If you have questions about marriage and family relationships, you can "ASK THE COUNSELOR." Address your questions to Mikal Frazier. Her address is
mikal@allaboutfamilies.org
Norman's e-mail address:
nlbales@allaboutfamilies.org